In the same way my scrawling high school handwriting has degraded through decades of PC word processing, so too have halt and record progress in a game diminished. The culprit is the emergence of autosave, checkpoints, console quick-resume features, and titles where the tension is so high that I can’t help but save obsessively just in case disaster strikes. But I’m not perfect. Laziness creeps in. And this week, I learned a crucial piece of wisdom deep into a session of the recently released Pokémon FireRed for Nintendo Switch: you still gotta manually hit save.
Many years had gone by since I engaged with one of the 2D Pokémon games — having missed the boat on the GBA era, the Generation II titles may have been the last mainline Poké-title I completed. Therefore, I was excited to pony up the asking price for the sentimental journey back to Kanto, and a quest gathering those first 151 pocket monsters. I quickly returned to the glory days. During a handful of gaming sessions, I was catching bugs, added Pikachu to my team, knocked out Brock with ease, took a chance on purchasing the Magikarp from the Man at the Pokémon Center, and journeyed through Mt. Moon completely unconcerned.
The fatal flaw: I failed to save even once! And never thought to.
Jigglypuff will never form a bond with the Mankey I caught.
Disaster struck during a session when I wasn't even playing… and where my kid took the console for a brief session of Pokémon Z-A instead, closing my game as a result. As we all know (something I temporarily forgot…) opening a new game on the system will close any software running. Your data is only preserved when an autosave triggers or after a manual save ahead of launching something else. Oops.
The Progression of Saving Progress: From Intentional to Invisible
One could view autosave, now so invisible most players barely notice it, as a bona fide “next-generation” advancement. Although the classic text game Zork had one of the earliest save functions in a game, 1986’s The Legend of Zelda is often credited as a pivotal point for not feeling utterly defeated after a game over because of persistent memory saves on the classic console. Of course, you still had to remember to save. (And after one flub), the lesson was learned for life. During the nineties, external memory cards including the original PlayStation normalized the save process though they were still vulnerable; neglecting to save (or misplacing a memory card) could erase countless hours. The survival horror series Resident Evil even turned saving into an item to be managed.
Contemporary background saving, the one that subdued my instinct to save my Pokémon adventure so effectively, took hold in the early 2000s. The original Halo pioneered seamless respawn points as the Call of Duty series honed the approach to streamline challenge and remove unnecessary grinding. As game worlds expanded — and more open-world — developers solved the puzzle of persistent, invisible saving and, finally, the pinnacle of picking up exactly where you left off.
The Pokémon Series' Path: From Deliberate Action to Automatic Assurance
Interestingly, the world of Pokémon is a great reflection of how saving has changed. For a long time, preserving your Pokédex progress was manual: players were trained to hit “Save” prior to shutting off their handheld console. A major change arrived in Pokémon Sword and Shield on the hybrid console, the games added an autosave feature (at first as a toggleable option), marking a major philosophical change for one of gaming’s most tradition-bound franchises.
I own up to my blunder: A long tenure with Breath of the Wild and recent platformers completely dulled my manual save reflex. I remain cautious in some cases — I won’t even gamble exiting prematurely in something like Hades 2 even knowing it has a robust save system — but be it because my extended absence from older game design, or I’ve just been spoiled, the thought never entered my mind to hit save before redocking. The child I once was would never have fumbled this badly.
The Result: Starting From Scratch
I have not returned to FireRed after my data loss incident. When I saw the title screen again to see I had only the beginning Squirtle, a wave of exhaustion hit me. Status condition: Burned.
Perhaps I'll restart… or perhaps I'll remain in the hundreds of new games available now that operate under the assumption I am incapable of manual saving. However, my love for retro gaming isn’t dead. On occasions when I can convince my daughter away from auto-saving Pokémon Legends: Z-A, we enjoy playing together some retro multiplayer mayhem. Those early SNES games omitted saving entirely opting instead for cryptic character strings. So, even if I blow myself up, it’s not a total loss. That provides some small solace.